brand strategy consultants

« May 2007 | June 2007 | July 2007 »

Zipf’s Law - The Power of Number One Number Two Brands

George Kingsley ZipfIn the 1930s, Harvard linguist George Kingsley Zipf found that “the” — the most-used English word — occurred about twice as often as “of” (second place), about three times as often as “and” (third) and so on.

All well and good, but how does Zipf’s Law apply to the discipline of branding? A recent study in Australia illustrates the power of branding in developing consumer preference and market share. From the New York Times:

Jan H. Hofmeyr, an expert on consumer behavior at Synovate…said he recently discovered that Zipf’s law also applied to the brand preferences of consumers and their spending habits.

“Marketers have always known it’s better to be No. 1 than No. 2, but now you can attach a revenue consequence to that,” Mr. Hofmeyr said.

Before being adopted by Synovate, Mr. Hofmeyr’s ideas were tested in Australia on two product categories: toilet paper and instant coffee. Consumers were asked to identify the brands they used and to rank them in order of preference.

According to his model, consumers who used four brands of toilet paper might have been expected to spend about 53 percent of their toilet paper budget on the top choice, 27 percent on the second brand, 13 percent on the third and 7 percent on the fourth.

In the Australian test case, consumers actually spent 50 percent on the top choice, 33 percent on the second, 9 percent on the third and 8 percent on the fourth. Averaged over hundreds of consumers, Mr. Hofmeyr said, the study showed an unusually high correlation between stated preferences and actual purchase decisions.

Zipf’s law…demonstrates the relative benefits of moving up in the rankings, Mr. Hofmeyr said. A product that leaps from second to first in a category can…affect a company’s bottom line, he said, while the advantage of moving up to, say, No. 5 from No. 6 is much smaller.

“With this approach, the moment you determine a brand’s ranking, you can predict the market share,” he said.

A real world understanding of Zipf’s Law is found in the Number One Number Two strategy initiated by Jack Welch early in his tenure as CEO of GE. If a GE business wasn’t first or second in its markets worldwide, or couldn’t be made so, it would be sold.

And how might any brand become number one or number two in its industry? By use of an own the conversation® strategy.

[More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More blogs about Brand Equity]

For Toronto, A Slogan Is Not A Brand

The new CEO of Tourism Toronto believes an effort to brand the city resulted in little more than creation of a new slogan and logo.

TorontoUnlimitedMore on this story from the Toronto Star:

In the summer of 2005, Tourism Toronto and its public sector partners (including the province, federal government and Toronto Summit Alliance) unveiled the results of a 13-month, $4 million search for a brand for the city. The result was “Toronto Unlimited” and a nifty water-droplet logo. The new look was launched with controversial ad campaigns that ran in The New York Times and other U.S. publications.

One set of ads promoted festivals and events that had already wrapped up, while another included an essay laden with inane thoughts and grammatically incorrect sentences. One example: “Toronto is nearly indefinable, nearly infinite in its possibilities for the traveller and nearly impossible to forget once you’ve been there. And perhaps what makes this place so original, so individual and somehow majestic is that it is a product of natural occurrences.”

The effort was immediately ridiculed by the media and was described by Mayor David Miller as an “embarrassment, indefensible.”

Rather than an engaging answer to the core question behind any great brand strategy - Why Do You Matter? - Toronto Unlimited reduces a great world city to the banality of just another e-commerce site such as Bags Unlimited, Furniture Unlimited, Shoes Unlimited and, yes, Crappie Unlimited.

New CEO, David Whitaker, most recently the chief marketing officer of the Miami Convention and Visitors Bureau, offers these opinions:

[H]e thinks it’s a mistake to get hung up on clever logos and catchy phrases. Having a brand, he says, is much more important. And it’s something he believes Toronto currently lacks. “I respectfully question whether Toronto Unlimited is a brand. It’s a tagline.”

We agree. A slogan is not a brand.

[More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More posts about | More blogs about Destination Branding]


« May 2007 | Home | July 2007 »